How do mineral and chemical sunscreens compare?

The comparison between mineral and chemical sunscreens, as discussed by Andrew Huberman on the Huberman Lab, highlights their respective benefits and potential drawbacks:

Mineral Sunscreens

1. Ingredients:
   • Typically contain zinc oxide and titanium dioxide.
2. Mechanism:
   • Work by physically reflecting UV light away from the skin.
3. Safety:
   • Considered safe for concentrations up to 25%.
   • Zinc oxide, particularly non-nano, is preferred due to minimal transdermal absorption concerns.
   • Less likely to cause endocrine disruption compared to chemical sunscreens.
4. Drawbacks:
   • Can feel thick and pasty, making application less pleasant.
   • Earlier formulations were notably visible on the skin (e.g., turning the nose white) 1.

Chemical Sunscreens

1. Ingredients:
   • Include compounds like oxybenzone and avobenzone.
2. Mechanism:
   • Absorb UV light instead of reflecting it.
3. Safety Concerns:
   • Some ingredients are potential endocrine disruptors, even at low levels.
   • Certain compounds (e.g., oxybenzone) have been shown to be absorbed into the bloodstream, raising safety concerns, especially at high application rates.
   • Could potentially cross the blood-brain barrier, raising additional health concerns 2 3.
     • 

       1

       Sunscreen Insights

       00:39:58
       
     • 

       2

       Sunscreen Safety Insights

       00:42:36
       
     • 

       3

       Sunscreen Safety Concerns

       01:36:48
       
     • 

       4

       Sunscreen Safety Insights

       00:46:37
       
     • 

       5

       Sunscreen Safety Insights

       00:44:37
       
4. Benefits:
   • Formulations tend to be more aesthetically pleasing, often clear and smooth on the skin.
   • Suitable for use over makeup and for everyday activities requiring a non-visible sunscreen 4.

Practical Recommendations

• Children: Avoid chemical sunscreens for children under six months to prevent potential endocrine disruption due to higher skin absorption 1.
• General Use: For those concerned about chemical exposure, mineral-based sunscreens are recommended. They are deemed safer for general use across all ages 2.
• Application: If chemical sunscreens are used, consider applying them sparingly and not daily, focusing only on areas most susceptible to burning 5.

In summary, if safety and minimal chemical exposure are priorities, mineral sunscreens are favored. Chemical sunscreens, while more aesthetically pleasing, carry potential risks that warrant cautious and limited use.